How would the Fourth Doctor react to the other Doctors?

[Graceful Leonard]

7th: Would be intresting to see the mind games that would occur.

Mind games would require at least two players with something approaching a personality. Tom would be talking to himself.

[Prydonian]

That was a little rude. Sure, if we do not like certain Doctors we are going to post to that effect, but there is a limit to what should be acceptable and what is not.

[Graceful Leonard]

That was a little rude. Sure, if we do not like certain Doctors we are going to post to that effect, but there is a limit to what should be acceptable and what is not.

Doubtless there is, but that is not for you to decide, thankfully.

[metalheadjay]

I don't think it was rude. Just cynical honesty. You've gotta be truthful even if it comes across as a bit of negativity by some.

[tch]

Why do people have to slam other Doctors in order to talk about how much they like Tom?

[MCH]

10th: "If you say "Alonsy" one more time I'll tell Leela to get the Janis thorns out".
11th "My God! I'm getting younger!"

Now those are funny ! Especially the 11th one.

MCH

[Graceful Leonard]

Why do people have to slam other Doctors in order to talk about how much they like Tom?

Speaking personally, I don't feel that I have to slam other doctors in order to say how much I like Tom. The topic of the thread is about how Tom would relate to the other doctors, so what I've said refers to the potential on-screen relationship between Tom's doctor and another. It's on topic.

I don't feel, either, that I'm being too harsh or rude. When someone chooses to become an actor in a high-profile show they make themselves a public figure open to criticism and judgement. In fact, without judgement of some kind they are doomed to fail. That's the price of fame.

So, if it is appropriate to the topic, I will express strong negative views about performances if I feel they are warranted. Without strong opinions, discussions are mere fluff. I shall let the good moderator of the site decide whether my comments cross the line, and accept that accordingly.

There, I hope we can now all get back to the topic in hand.

[tracy]

OK guys this is getting abit out of hand now dont you think . dont let a subject get to you where you all end up fighting your making a light hearted disscussion turn into a very over heated one where you will end up falling out with each other

[MCH]

Have a jelly baby.

[Prydonian]

Dear Graceful Leonard,

Despite Tracy's plea, I am going to make this comment.

Neither is it up to you to decide which Doctors should be needlessly crticised.
If you want a Moderator brought in, go for it. I am not scared of such things.